Our Santa Fe River, Inc.

www.oursantaferiver.org

1-386-454-2366

oursantafe@hotmail.com
 
Welcome Newcomers to this posting. 
 
I post a weekly e-mail update on current water issues locally, nationally and worldly with the main emphasis on water bottling and quality on the Santa Fe River in north central Florida.  
 
If you wish to be removed from this weekly e-mail please contact Merrillee at Merrilleeart@aol.com
 
Hello,
 
Thank you all for doing your share in helping the Santa Fe River this past week.  I have included below several posting relating to the Gilchrist County "Quasi-Judicial" Hearing September 30, 2008. 
 
Here are details on Sept. 30th meeting (Blue Springs request for a "special use permit" to build a water bottling facility on CR 340, Poe Springs Road, in Gilchrist County, Florida).
 
The meeting began 6 pm Sept. 30 and the vote was taken at 12:30 am the following day October 1, 2008... 6 1/2 hour meeting!
 
The vote was  4...no and  1...yes
The Gilchrist Board of Commissioners voted like this...
Kenrick Thomas...no
Randy Durden...no
Tommy Langford, chairman of the board,...yes
Sharon Langford...no   (we've been told no relation to Tommy)
D. Ray Harrison...no
 
There were over 250 people present and over 100 people spoke against the "special use" permit to build a water bottling facility on CR 340 in northern Gilchrist County, Florida.  Throughout the night, we were allowed to question the "experts" the Blue Springs lawyer, Mr. Ray Earl Thomas Jr., brought to the meeting.  He was also allowed to question many of the audience members who chose to speak out against this plant.  Only one citizen from the audience spoke in favor of the proposal; his name is Steve Gladin.
 
The main concerns people expressed were quality of life issues, noise from the plant and traffic, pollution relating to the light and traffic (the plant will run 24/7), withdraws of water, compatibility with a rural, agricultural, residential neighborhood.  There is a bottling plant Coca-Cola operates less than 1 mile from this proposed sight and many residents complained about this facility and used it as a precurser as to why another one would be another bad idea.
 
Kim Davis, owner of Blue Springs, refused to say which corporation she was working with; citing a confidentiality agreement.
 
Generally speaking the citizens stuck to these issues because the water withdraw permit purchased by Blue Springs from the Suwannee River Water Management District back in 2003 was stated as a district issue and not a county issue.  OSFR maintains that local governments need to work with the Florida State Water District agencies that issue consumptive use permits.  This is not the case in Florida however...a person/company can apply and pay for a permit before all construction permits are in place.  Giving a false impression that because the state gives them a permit that it is a given that they get the necessary permits to build from local governments. 
 
The night before the meeting one of our "members" (our members are people who receive our e-mail and respond or simply asked to be on our e-mail list) sent us this document...basically it says that local governments must work with state and federal agencies to plan for our future water use in terms of growth.
 
(1) That the proposed use and associated development is consistent with the Gilchrist
County Comprehensive Plan, and
complies with all required regulations and standards of
this Land Development Code and other applicable regulations.
 
The plan before you FAILS in all material respects to comply with State and Federal Law
 
TO WIT:
 
EXHIBIT ONE:

Division of Community Planning


Division Home | Statutes and Rules | D.R.I. Procedures | Comp Plan Procedures | Reports and Notices Online

Water Supply Planning

Recognizing the importance of an adequate water supply to Florida's future, the Legislature has established a process for water supply planning through Florida's Growth Management Act (Chapter 163, Part II, Florida Statutes) and the Water Protection and Sustainability Program (Chapter 373, Florida Statutes). Under this system, the state's five water management districts must periodically evaluate whether adequate water supplies exist to meet the needs of their areas. If a district finds that the water supply will not be adequate, it must prepare regional water supply plans for those areas, identifying how water supply needs can be met for the next 20 years. Local governments that fall within the area of a regional water supply plan are required to ensure that adequate water supplies will be available to meet future demand, by developing 10-year water supply facilities work plans. These work plans include alternative water supplies, water reuse and conservation programs, and they are incorporated into the local governments' comprehensive plans. In addition, all local governments - regardless of whether they are in one of these planning areas - must address water supply in their concurrency management programs.

Since July 2005, the Department has required that local governments submitting comprehensive plan amendments include data and analysis to demonstrate that water supplies are sufficient to support anticipated growth.

Water Supply Concurrency

Section 163.3180(2)(a), Florida Statutes, requires local governments to consult with water suppliers to ensure that adequate water supplies will be in place and available to serve new development no later than when the local government issues a certificate of occupancy or its functional equivalent. Local governments should update their comprehensive plans and land development regulations as soon as possible to address this water supply concurrency requirement.

Local Government 10-Year Water Supply Facilities Work Plans

The state's water management districts have updated their regional water supply plans, which identify areas where water supply shortages are projected to occur within the next 20 years. The regional water supply plans identify alternative projects to be implemented by local governments in these areas, in order to supplement their traditional sources of water to meet projected demand.

Pursuant to Section 163.3177(6)(c), Florida Statutes, local governments that are subject to a regional water supply plan must adopt a 10-year water supply facilities work plan in their comprehensive plans (see Due Dates for Adopting 10-Year Water Supply Facilities Work Plan Amendments). These local water supply facilities work plans must identify alternative water supply projects - from among those listed in the appropriate regional water supply plan or, those proposed by the local governments themselves (Section 373.0361(7)(b), Florida Statutes) - that the local government will implement to meet existing and future development needs.

Water Supply Guidelines

The Department, in cooperation with the Department of Environmental Protection and the state's water management districts, has prepared three technical assistance documents. The first, A Guide for Local Governments in Preparing Water Supply Comprehensive Plan Amendments and Water Supply Facilities Work Plans, has been prepared to help local governments understand their water supply planning responsibilities pursuant to Chapter 163, Part II, Florida Statutes. It addresses the scope and content of required 10-year water supply facilities work plans, identifies data and analysis local governments must provide, and includes recommendations for adopting the work plan into the comprehensive plan. It also identifies sources of information available to local governments and the deadlines for adopting the required work plans and comprehensive plan amendments.

The second document, entitled Recommendations for Preparing Water Supply and Facility Data and Analysis to Support Local Comprehensive Plan Amendments, describes the water supply and facilities data and analysis that local governments should submit with proposed comprehensive plan amendments, particularly those that would change the Future Land Use Map to increase density or intensity. Examples in the guide describe the basic information and analysis that local governments should consider to support the adoption of a proposed land use change.

The third document, Agency Coordination of Comprehensive Planning and Water Supply Planning in Florida, describes and updates processes used by reviewing agencies and the Department when reviewing comprehensive plan amendments and Evaluation and Appraisal Reports related to water supply planning. The guide also provides a comprehensive list of statutory and rule requirements related to water supply planning.

Examples of Adopted Water Supply Facilities Work Plans

The Department has found the following adopted local government 10-year Water Supply Facilities Work Plans in compliance. They are available for viewing and download on our Comprehensive Plan and Plan Amendment Archive (FloridaPAPERS) web page.

  • Groveland 07-1
  • Lake Mary 07RWSP1
  • Martin County 07-2
  • Palm Coast 07RWSP1
  • Sanford 07-RWSP1
  • Seminole County 07RWSP1
  • Winter Springs 07RWSP1

Water Protection and Sustainability Program

To address the challenge of ensuring that Florida has an adequate water supply, the 2005 Legislature enacted the Water Protection and Sustainability Program (Chapter 373, Florida Statutes). The law encourages cooperation among municipalities, counties and the state's five water management districts to protect and develop water supplies. The law requires water management districts to promote alternative water supply projects - for example, using reclaimed water and stormwater - that accommodate growth while reducing the use of traditional ground and surface water supplies, such as aquifers and lakes.

For more information about the program and to view links to regional water supply plans, please contact the water management district in your region:

Northwest Florida Water Management District

Paul Thorpe, AICP, Director
Resource Planning Section
paul.thorpe@nwfwmd.state.fl.us
(850) 539-5999; (800) 913-1518
www.nwfwmd.state.fl.us

This was not sent to us by Paul Thorpe, although he is the author.  It was forwarded to us by Leonard  Wheeler, and I am very grateful.  I believe this is a sound and valid arguement against building more of these plants in Florida. 
 
I am also very grateful for all the citizens participation.  Let this inspire all of us to move forward to make a difference in our future growth.  It is up to us on how we want our communities to grow  and our elected officials must be obligated simply by being elected by the citizens to carry out our will.
 
The next Gilchrist County vision meeting is this week Tuesday Oct. 7th @ 6 pm at the Trenton High School.  If you care about your county please attend and let the County Planners know what you want in your neighborhoods.
please read...
http://highspringsherald.com/articles/2008/10/03/news/news15.txt 
 
Best Wishes,
Merrillee Malwitz-Jipson
board member OSFR
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Officials say no to water plant near High Springs



GILCHRIST COUNTY -- They came from High Springs, Alachua, Fort White, Trenton, Bell and Suwannee -- more than 250 people gathered in Trenton to voice their opposition to a proposed bottled water plant on the Santa Fe River.

read more...  

http://highspringsherald.com/articles/2008/10/03/news/news01.txt 
 
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Local Activists, Our Santa Fe River and Food & Water Watch Halt Attempt to Privatize Gilchrist County Water as County Commission Denies “Special Use” Permit for New Water Extraction Facility

October 2, 2008

Contact:

Jorge Aguilar or Kate Fried, Food & Water Watch (202) 683-2500
 
http://www.foodandwaterwatch.org/press/releases/local-activists-our-santa-fe-river-and-food-water-watch-halt-attempt-to-privatize-gilchrist-county-water-as-county-commission-denies-201cspecial-use201d-permit-for-new-water-extraction-facility20081002
 
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
STOPNESTLEWATERS.ORG
 
http://stopnestlewaters.org/2008/10/01/success-gilchrist-county-denies-water-bottling-plant-permit/179
 
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Gainesville Sun Newspaper
 

Dr. Robert L. Knight: Saving Silver Springs can’t wait forever

Published: Sunday, September 28, 2008 at 5:04 p.m.
Last Modified: Sunday, September 28, 2008 at 5:05 p.m.

I first visited Silver Springs in August 1953. I was only 5 years old and little did I know that a three-year landmark ecological study was under way under the direction of a new, young professor at the University of Florida named Howard T. Odum.

read more....

http://www.gainesville.com/article/20080928/OPINION03/809280253 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 
For maps, latitude/longitude data, driving directions, satellite imagery, and topographic representations as well as  weather conditions at this spring, go to Greg Johnson's informative "Florida Springs Database" web site at the following address:  http://www.ThisWaytothe.Net/springs/floridasprings.htm#Florida  
 
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Dear Brothers and Sisters in Gilchrist County,
 
Congratulations on this wonderful victory!!
 
I am so happy for you, and the Santa Fe, and those of us fighting to protect the St. Johns River honor your hard work and commitment.
 
I'm in Sanford for our administrative hearing challenging the St. Johns Water Management District's CUP permit that would allow Seminole County to remove 5.5 MGD from the St. Johns River.  The hearing will probably go for almost three weeks.
 
We're facing a uphill battle. Seminole County is spending $2.4 million to defend this destructive project.  When built out, Yankee Lake will remove over 70 MGD from the river. This permit is the camel's nose under the tent. Orlando and other central Florida cities and communities want to take over 262 MGD from the St. Johns and Ocklawaha Rivers.
 
We believe we have a chance, and our legal team will represent us well. Hopefully, our hearing will help all of us fighting to protect our rivers and springs.
 
I 'm posting a blog on our website from the hearing so folks can keep up with what's going on.
 
To find the blog, go to stjohnsriverkeeper.org and click on the link under the cartoon man sucking water from a straw.
 
Once again, congratulations and thanks for all your hard work.
 
Take care, all.
 
For the River,
 
Neil
      

Neil A. Armingeon

St. Johns Riverkeeper

2800 University Blvd.

Jacksonville, FL 32211

904-256-7591

narming@ju.edu

stjohnsriverkeeper.org

Ubi dubium ibi libertas 

 

WATER WARS: Hearing begins on tapping St. Johns


Click-2-Listen javascript:OpenC2LWindow('Morris','tu-online_stories_100208_met_339182581','', 'OAS_sitepage=' + OAS_sitepage, 'Jacksonville', '', 'Production');void(0);

Lawyers air arguments on river withdrawals in Central Florida.


 

SANFORD - A high-stakes legal fight over using St. Johns River water in Central Florida utilities opened Wednesday with lawyers arguing about the need for and impact of the river withdrawal.

read more...

http://www.jacksonville.com/tu-online/stories/100208/met_339182581.shtml

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

FOR MORE INFORMATION CONTACT:

Holly Stalvey  386.362.1001

 

 

SRWMD Closes on Otter Springs Property

 

LIVE OAK(Oct. 1, 2008)— Two second magnitude springs and over a mile of frontage on the Suwannee River were given a new level of protection on Tuesday when the Suwannee River Water Management District closed on the purchase of the 636-acre Otter Springs property in Gilchrist County.

The $6.8 million purchase will not only protect water quality and natural communities associated with the river and springs, it will eliminate a 400,000 gallon per day water use permit. Although no plans were on the table, the permit would have allowed the water to be pumped from underground conduits feeding the spring and sent to a bottling plant. 

The transaction was also the springboard for a new cooperative venture between the District and the Gilchrist County Commission. On Monday, commissioners voted unanimously to authorize county staff to develop an agreement with the District to assume the immediate management of the property. The parties are to work out a long-term lease of the property which must be approved by both the County Commission and the District Governing Board.

Under the proposed agreements, the county will assume day-to-day responsibilities for the 100-site RV campground on the property and the associated recreational facilities. The District will continue to assist with the management of the natural areas on the property. The plan will ensure that an outstanding recreational resource will be available to the citizens of the region as well as providing economic development through nature-based tourism.

 

 

Holly Stalvey

Communication Coordinator

Suwannee River Water Management District

9225 CR 49

Live Oak, FL 32060

(386) 362-1001

Fax: (386) 362-1056

Toll free: 800-226-1066 (FL only)

 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Experts, authors talk water at Santa Fe forum

Published: Friday, October 3, 2008 at 6:01 a.m.
Last Modified: Saturday, October 4, 2008 at 12:22 a.m.

Writer and journalist Cynthia Barnett thinks the state’s water policy is swimming against a current of common sense ideas.

read more....

http://www.gainesville.com/article/20081003/NEWS/810049981

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Water Bottling Plant in Marianna, Florida

This is an e-mail exchange I had regarding the $750,000 Community Development Block Grant that recently "awarded" to build infrastructure for a water bottling plant in Marianna, Florida (located near the Chatahoochee River and the Florida Caverns State Park).  If any of you live up in that vicinity...you may want to get involved.    -- Merrillee


Mr. Lakey,

We have received an inquiry about the County's CDBG Economic Development grant for the water bottling facility in the Marianna industrial park. There is no indication that the County was contacted about this project and has addressed the inquiry. Therefore, I am requesting the County respond, within 15 days, to  Ms. Malwitz-Jipson  under your citizen participation policy, even though she may not reside in Jackson County.

Since her inquiry was received by e-mail, you may respond by e-mail with a hard copy to the project file. Also,  please copy me on the e-mail response. (You may or may not want to copy all the other persons she copied.)

Please include in your response information about the public hearings (notice date and comments, if any) and water permit issue. You may also want to include the "build out" economic development benefits of this project: job creation, private investment amount, and tax base increase over the first and future phases.

Thanks!

In addition, I'm providing for Ms.Malwitz-Jipson's review a link to the Florida State Clearinghouse review comments which all federally assisted projects undergo. Both The DEP and NW Water Management District reviewed the application and provided no negative comments regarding environmental impact.  Therefore, I am unaware of any issue which would preclude this project from going forward.

http://appprod.dep.state.fl.us/clearinghouse/applicant/project.asp?chips_project_id=59061  

Steve Fellerman
Small Cities CDBG Program
850-922-1881 (direct)
850-922-5609 (fax)


The Department of Community Affairs is committed to maintaining the highest levels of service and values your feedback.  Please take a few moments to complete our Customer Service Survey by visiting http://www.dca.state.fl.us/CustomerServiceSurvey/.  We look forward to hearing from you. However, if you require assistance or a response from the agency, please use the "Contact Us" webpage at http://www.dca.state.fl.us/contactus/.

The Florida Discount Drug Card is designed to lower the cost of prescriptions for certain Florida residents. To learn more, visit http://www.FloridaDiscountDrugCard.com or call toll-free 1-866-341-8894 or TTY 1-866-763-9630.

Florida has a broad public records law and all correspondence, including email addresses, may be subject to disclosure.

----- Forwarded by Steve Fellerman/DCA/FLEOC on 10/02/2008 09:39 AM -----

Anastasia Richmond/DCA/FLEOC

10/02/2008 09:00 AM

To
Steve Fellerman/DCA/FLEOC@fleoc
cc
Mark Yelland/DCA/FLEOC@fleoc
Subject
Fw: Water Bottle Plant gets $750,000 from Florida Grant Money




Steve,

Can you answer and of Ms. Malwitz-Jipson about how Marianna about the CDBG process?

Thanks.

Ana



The Department of Community Affairs is committed to maintaining the highest levels of service and values your feedback.  Please take a few moments to complete our Customer Service Survey by visiting http://www.dca.state.fl.us/CustomerServiceSurvey/.  We look forward to hearing from you. However, if you require assistance or a response from the agency, please use the "Contact Us" webpage at http://www.dca.state.fl.us/contactus/.

The Florida Discount Drug Card is designed to lower the cost of prescriptions for certain Florida residents. To learn more, visit http://www.FloridaDiscountDrugCard.com or call toll-free 1-866-341-8894 or TTY 1-866-763-9630.

Florida has a broad public records law and all correspondence, including email addresses, may be subject to disclosure.

----- Forwarded by Anastasia Richmond/DCA/FLEOC on 10/02/2008 08:58 AM -----

Merrilleeart@aol.com

10/02/2008 06:40 AM

To
anastasia.richmond@dca.state.fl.us, oelrich.steve.web@flsenate.gov, debbie.boyd@myfloridahouse.gov, Charlie.Crist@eog.myflorida.com, ndflagg@gmail.com, byerly@alltel.net, citymanager1@alltel.net, commissioner@doacs.state.fl.us, Saunders.Burt.web@flsenate.gov, Dockery.paula.web@flsenate.gov, Gaetz.don.web@flsenate.gov, rich.nan.web@flsenate.gov, Jones.dennis.web@flsenate.gov, Justice.charlie.web@flsenate.gov, lynn_bannister@billnelson.senate.gov, DAS@srwmd.org, HLS@srwmd.org, Teresa.Jacobs@ocfl.net, billconradconstruction@yahoo.com, buddylamb@bellsouth.net, Bob.Graham@grahamcos.com, bbanton@barackobama.com, Tim@TimCunha.com, drew.bartlett@dep.state.fl.us, cpattison@1000fof.org, Susie_PerezQuinn@billnelson.senate.gov, Nancy_Koepke@billnelson.senate.gov, Michelle_Barth@billnelson.senate.gov
cc
lazylanecottages@alltel.net, augie12@windstream.net, mstrawn@earthlink.net, alterrrx@yahoo.com, Karldowda@aol.com, dsg@internationalrealtyglobal.com, topsail@windstream.net, rivergal@windstream.net, jaguilar@fwwatch.org, dlapidus@stopcorporateabuse.org, richard@polarisinstitute.org, stan_meeks@earthlink.net, LWheeler45@aol.com
Subject
Water Bottle Plant gets $750,000 from Florida Grant Money


Hello,
 
Does anyone know how these people/corporation/city government got $750,000 of our state dollars to assist in building a water bottle facility in Marianna, Florida (near Florida Caverns Sate Park)?
 
This is a terrible idea.  Especially making our tax payer money available to use our public natural resources during drought conditions with Georgia, Alabama, and Florida last year.  
 
Who's idea was this anyhow...the City of Marianna or Enterprise Florida?  This must be stopped...is it too late?
 
Please take into the account of the recent victory in Trenton,Florida, Wednesday morning October 1, 2008.  A smaller rural town needing jobs, just like Marianna.  The full story will be at highspringsherald.com later today.  The majority of people in Florida do not want anymore of these extraction plants taking our water and putting it in plastic and shipping it to the ends of the earth.
 
This money needs to be used to repair our water infrastructure and make good healthy water available to everyone so that people ween themselves off the wasteful, luxury plastic bottle.
 
Sincerely,
Merrillee Malwitz-Jipson
board member Our Santa Fe River, Inc
Merrilleeart@aol.com
oursantaferiver.org    
 

Complete story....read here...

http://www.newsherald.com/news/county_68465___article.html/community_jobs.html

and more about the company...

The Polaris Institute in Ottawa prepared a corporate profile on Ice River Springs a couple of years ago. You can access it here: http://www.polarisinstitute.org/aquafarms_profile
 
Here is a link to an article I wrote in late '07 about Ice River Springs' expansion plans in Indiana and New Hampshire. You can read it here: http://www.polarisinstitute.org/files/Nov2007newsbytes.pdf
 
Richard Girard
Polaris Institute Researcher
180 Metcalfe St. Suite 500
Ottawa, Ontario
K2P 1P5
(613) 237-1717 105
1-866-346-6602
Fax (613) 237-3359
www.polarisinstitute.org